The Mast is Upon Us…

Oak woodlands are one of California’s most important habitat types, “have[ing] higher levels of biodiversity than virtually any other terrestrial ecosystem in California.” (Elizabeth A. Bernhardt and Tedmund J. Swiecki, 2019). As intense wildfire continues to drive type conversion, with many of our old growth oak woodlands slowly being converted to invaded grasslands, there is a clear need to include trees into restoration strategies in addition to shrubs, sub-shrubs, and native grasses that are common in many of our revegetation efforts.

Acorn from Canyon live oak (Quercus chrysolepis)

Oaks trees, dependent on species, produce acorns in large amounts irregularly (every other year to as many as every 4 years), these large crop events are known as mast years. This year happens to be a mast year for many oak trees in the red oak group, including Black oak (Quercus kelloggii) and Canyon live oak (Q. chrysolepis). These are two of the dominant oak species on the San Bernardino National Forest (SBNF). Due to this increased production of acorns this year, it has been a restoration priority to collect as many as we can while the crop is so bountiful.

Collecting acorns comes with its own unique challenges compared to other seeds I have collected throughout this field season. For starters, oak trees get tall. The trees with the most acorns are the oldest and largest and thus they dangle this precious restoration resource high above the forest floor. Unless you happen to have some stilts or a giant on your restoration staff you have to get a bit creative in how you overcome this challenge. On our team we decided the best strategy for acorn retrieval was to start by finding the longest stick available, that could be the end of a rake, a hula hoe, or a branch. This stick served one purpose, to shake acorns from the high branches we mere humans could not reach on our own.

A second challenge in acorn collection, at least in the SBNF, is Phytophthora. In order to prevent introducing this plant pathogen into our nursery stock we never collect seed that has already fallen to the forest floor. This meant we could not just shake branches and pick up what fell to our feet. Instead, we spread out a large tarp beneath the oak tree canopy and caught as many of the falling acorns as we could before they hit the floor beneath us. It often felt like this could be a new mini game in the next Mario Party (or does this already exist? If not it should, Nintendo call me).

Jorge Rodriguez (SBNF, left), Lili Ortega (IERCD, right), and myself (center) demonstrating our go to technique for acorn collection on a Black oak (Q. kelloggii).

Now lets not forget the fact that acorns are not just used by restoration teams like the one here at the SBNF. There is also the challenge of competition for this limited resource with the native residence of the forest. Tree squirrels love acorns for they are packed with energy and can be easily eaten in half the time as harder nuts. They also bury and store a large amount of the acorns they collect, making them perhaps natures original restorationists.

We also compete with less furry creatures that use acorns for their nutritious insides, acorn weevils. Acorn weevils lay their larvae inside of, you guessed it, acorns. A clear tell that an acorn may be home to a growing larvae is a small circular exit hole somewhere on the exterior of the acorn. Squirrels and other forest animals often leave these damaged acorns behind and by the time we reach the oak trees a large amount of what remains may be already occupied by these larvae. At some point Jorge, my cabin mate at the Forest Service barracks, and I found countless larvae on the dinner table after storing an acorn collection bag there overnight before bringing them into our main office, not a fun discovery first thing in the AM.

In order to sort out damaged acorns from those acorns that have the highest probability of germinating, a common strategy used is a float test. A float test is pretty much what it sounds like, a container is filled with water and acorns are added in with some floating to the top and other sinking to the bottom of the container. Those acorns that float are usually lighter due to some damage to the oak embryo inside. Heavy full acorns are usually full of the nutrients needed to support a young oak seedling early in its development. Therefore, the floating acorns were skimmed off the top and disposed of with only the sinking acorns being utilized in our final collection. Additionally, any acorns that sunk but had any visual signs of weevil damage (i.e. clear exit holes) were removed from our final collection.

Myself doing the final step of a float test and pouring off the water so we can collect the healthy full acorns from the bottom of our container (in this case a 5gal plastic bucket).

Overall, our acorn collecting efforts so far this year have felt like a success. For the end of my time at the SBNF we will be cleaning, weighing, and assigning accession numbers to our final seed collections including all of our precious acorns. So, TBD (to be determined) on the final weights of our acorn collections. It feels like my time here at the SBNF has flown by and I am not ready to say goodbye to this beautiful place. But, alas, all great things must come to an end. For now I am just cherishing each day and trying to learn as much as I can as I begin searching for what will be coming up next for me. I know the first hand experience and connections I have gained through the CLM internship experience will help give me the ability to excel in whatever natural resources position I put my efforts toward in the future.

The Plants We Seek on Bertha Peak

The San Bernardino National Forest (SBNF) is a patchwork of unique microhabitats due to the geologic history of the region. Up until approximately 5 million years ago portions of San Bernardino county remained submerged beneath an ancient ocean (Kottkamp, 2023). The deposition of ancient sea shells, coral, and algae in Big Bear Valley formed limestone deposits which helped form soils rich in calcium carbonate (Faber, 2017). These deposits are valuable from both an economic perspective (limestone/dolomite mining for cement production) and an ecological perspective (supporting edaphic species; those that exist on only one soil type). The management of these areas have been outlined by the San Bernardino Forest Association’s Carbonate Habitat Management Strategy (CHMS, 2003). This plan attempts to facilitate economic activity (i.e. mining) while conserving the carbonate plants unique to the region. Part of this strategy includes the surveying of populations identified as threatened and endangered (T&E). This month I got to assist on a surveying project led by the mountaintop district botanist, Joseph Esparza, meant to identify populations of T&E carbonate plants located within a proposed prescribed burn area.

Members of our field crew making the ascent up the rocky carbonate slopes of Bertha Peak. August 21, 2024.

Our first surveying day began the morning of August 5th. We took off from the Big Bear Discovery Center and drove about 20 minutes northeast to a minor summit on the north shore of Big Bear Lake, Bertha Peak. After arriving at the trailhead we began to hike to the treatment area which required about a 1 mile trek with approximately 800 ft of elevation gain. As a relatively fit southern California hiker I did not feel too intimidated at first. However, hiking an incline at elevation was a unique challenge as our bodies’ slowly acclimated to the conditions. We were SWEATING. But the challenge felt worth it to take in not only the view of Big Bear Valley but the unique assemblage of plant species colonizing the steep carbonate hillsides and mixed conifer woodlands on our way up to the peak. On our way up Joseph pointed out key carbonate species we would need to keep an eye out for including: Eriogonum ovalifolim var. vineum, Dudleya abramsii ssp. affinis, Abronia nana var. covillei, and Astragalus leucolobus. All of these carbonate plant species have been identified as threatened by the state of California. 

Surveying for T&E species requires more than just marking a location on a map. When we came across an unmapped population of one of these carbonate plant species we, of course, created a polygon around the population perimeter. We also recorded associated species, phenology information, habitat description, and any signs of disturbance in the area. All of this data was recorded digitally using arcGIS field maps. Conducting these surveys helped sharpen my skills in native species identification and habitat classification. These are beneficial skills I will bring to any future surveying projects I assist on (or one day lead myself!). 

Holding the main tool of the surveying trade (my tablet with Field Maps) while standing at the base of a rocky slope and mapping a population of Coville’s dwarf sand verbena (A. nana var, covillei).

On that initial surveying day, forest botany tech Taylor Edwards and I surveyed multiple populations of E. ovalifolium tucked into the rocky southern facing slopes of Bertha Peak. On the second day I got to work with a field tech from the Inland Empire Resource Conservation District (IERCD), Lili Ortega. Lili and I surveyed a single population of A. nana containing 155 individuals and stretching 7,723 ft2 across another south-facing carbonate slope. This population was a particular challenge due to the irregular population margins and the scattered distribution of individuals within it. One of the major observations I made while surveying this area was that we were identifying the correct habitat type before we really began to hunt for individuals. There was no use heavily sweeping every inch of the duff soils in the denser areas of Pine and Juniper woodland that also inhabit the ridge as these areas were too crowded and did not possess the correct soil type to support these unique carbonate species. Instead we would quickly sweep through these denser areas until we came across the next rocky slope and those areas are where the true investigation began. An ecological eye requires an eye that is attuned to both the biotic members of our ecosystem (the plants) as well as the abiotic (soil type, slope, and aspect).

Lili Ortega (left) and myself (right) carefully scanning one of Bertha Peak’s slopes for T&E carbonate plant species.

I got to tag-a-long to a third day hiking the path up and along Bertha Peak. This final day involved Taylor, Lili, and I joining forces surveying toward one of the southeastern edges of the proposed treatment area. I was able to identify a small population of A. leucolobus on my own which increased my confidence in identifying this species as it was one I had not surveyed previously. We also surveyed a new population of A. nana, this time inhabiting a northwestern facing slope instead of the southwest facing slopes we had grown accustomed to. We capped the day with a final sweep of the outer perimeter of the treatment area but no suitable habitat was observed here, and thus no further populations were identified. This month helped teach me that the forest leaves clues for those with eyes trained to pick up on them. A particular geology type, a fallen tree, or track in the mud all possess within them a story. I am excited by the prospect that the more and more I work in this field the more my eyes become attuned to the narrative the land is trying to tell.  

Prickly Predicaments

My first month working at the San Bernardino National Forest has been so much fun! After participating in a lot of amazing projects, we were finally able to start making some seed collections at the end of the month.

Our first collection site

Don’t Hug A Yucca

Interior goldenbush (Ericameria linearfolia) was one of our first contenders for seed collection. Big Bear has had an especially wet year, so even though these guys were among the first on our list for collection, they actually went to seed a bit later in the season than usual.

Ericameria linearifolia

On the day we showed up for collection, there were seeding Ericameria linearifolia as far as the eye could see. It was any new seed collector’s dream! I set out with my labeled bag and started collecting. After about half an hour of collecting from various smaller plants, I saw the perfect goldenbush. It was huge and every flower was seeding with very little seed dispersed! I knew I was going to be at this one for a while, so I crouched down beside it and then…

Not the yucca in question, but a close friend of his I’m sure

I literally sat on a yucca! It hurt so bad and started bleeding a bit immediately, but luckily the pain went away pretty quickly and I continued seed collecting. Regardless, contrary to what the sticker at our Regional Botanist’s desk might say, fellow seed collectors, don’t “Hug a Yucca”!

Thistle Be Interesting

At the same site, I helped Koby, a Biological Restoration Technician, with the collection of some native cobweb thistle (Cirsium occidentale). This plant species isn’t on our CLM seed collection list, but it’s on the general SBNF seed collection list and its elusive nature intrigued me.

See this thistle has what I’d refer to as a close evil invasive twin… Cirsium vulgare. Even the name sounds like bad news! Seeing them side by side in the pictures above, the differences are pretty clear. But in the field, when you’re worried about accidentally collecting from an invasive and looking at just one of the species on their own, the differences seem less apparent. During my first week on the job, I learned that several forestry techs at our office were wary of collecting from our native cobweb thistle and reluctant to pull bull thistle for fear of choosing the wrong Cirsium.

Since then, I took a special interest in telling these twins apart. I learned that bull thistle tends to look meaner, greener, and the leaf tips extend in a way that looks like it’s giving you the finger for just looking at it. Vulgare indeed… I also learned that bull thistle tends to like moister soils near water while cobweb thistle prefers well drained soils. Our native cobweb thistle also has dark seeds and the leaves are generally more narrow, sage green, and overall just look like they’re adapted to a drier climate. Having conversations about the differences between these two thistle has given a lot of us at the office more confidence around telling these two apart. I was so pleased to hear one of my coworkers come up to me the other day with a HUGE bag of thistle seed and proudly say “I’m not afraid of thistle anymore!”. Ana Karina and I are hoping to collect vouchers of these two thistles so they can be displayed side by side and help future SBNF employees and interns!

The Ants Beat Us To It!

The ants beat us to it! (Stipa speciosa)

Finally, we also collected Stipa speciosa (Desert needle grass). We learned that the tail on Stipa seeds bend to a right angle when the seeds are fully matured. What I was truly fascinated by, though, was finding this grass bunch where ants were harvesting seed! They were slowly pulling the seeds out and we saw a trail of ants hauling seeds back to the ant hill. I recently learned that some plants have a special relationship with ants in which ants will take the seeds with them underground effectively planting the seeds and allowing the plants to grow. Who knew ants were seed collectors and gardeners too!

I’m so excited to continue learning about our California natives and being a part of some great projects in the month of July. Also, we will finally be getting our own tablets!! I hope everyone is having as much fun as I’ve been having and I’m so glad to be a part of such a great program!